📰 Insights · Money

Thinking of switching life insurance? Compare the old and new cover before you cancel

Switching protection can save money or get you cover that fits your life better. It can also leave you paying more for less, or with no cover at all if the order of events goes wrong. Here is how to compare properly.

In short: replacing a life insurance, critical illness or income protection policy can make sense, but a lower premium alone doesn't show that the new policy is better. A new application means fresh underwriting at your current age and health, and possibly different definitions, exclusions or premium terms. Compare the two contracts side by side, and never cancel existing cover until the replacement has been accepted on final terms and is in force.

Why the FCA has looked at switching

In its pure protection market study, finalised in September 2026, the Financial Conduct Authority found a risk that commission structures could encourage some intermediaries to move customers to a new policy once the original commission could no longer be clawed back, even where the new policy does not suit the customer better or offers less value. The FCA calls this “unnecessary switching”.

It is important to keep this in proportion. The FCA estimated that around 19,000 customers a year may be affected, roughly 0.1% of policyholders, and decided that market-wide intervention would be disproportionate. It will deal with firms that behave badly through supervision instead. It also said clearly that not all switching is harmful: people's circumstances change, and the ability to switch can matter. Our article on the FCA's findings has more detail.

Good reasons to review, and possibly change, your cover

  • Your mortgage has changed. You have remortgaged, moved, borrowed more or paid off a large chunk, so decreasing cover no longer matches the balance.
  • Your family has changed. A new partner, a new baby, children leaving home, separation or divorce.
  • Your income has changed. A significant pay rise may mean your income protection is too small. Going self-employed may mean employer benefits have disappeared.
  • Your health has improved. For example, you have stopped smoking for at least 12 months, or lost a significant amount of weight. Some insurers may then offer better terms.
  • Your old policy no longer does the job. For example, a critical illness policy from many years ago with fewer conditions or no partial payments, where newer wording would cover more.

A review should come before a switch. Sometimes the best answer is to adjust what you have, or to add a small top-up policy, rather than replace everything.

Why a fresh application can turn out differently

A new policy is a new contract. The insurer will underwrite you as you are today:

  • You are older. Premiums for the same cover generally rise with age, so a new policy must do something better to justify the change.
  • Your health may have changed. Any condition diagnosed since your existing policy began could lead to a higher premium, an exclusion, a postponement or a decline. Your existing policy cannot be changed because of new health conditions.
  • Your job or hobbies may have changed. A move into a riskier occupation can affect terms, especially for income protection.
  • The definitions will be different. Newer critical illness policies often cover more conditions, but particular definitions vary, and in some cases an older wording may be more generous on a specific condition.
  • New early-years terms. A new life policy usually starts a fresh suicide exclusion period, typically the first year.

The side-by-side comparison

Put your current policy documents and the new insurer's final offer next to each other and work through these points:

CheckWhat to compare
PurposeMortgage repayment, family income, income replacement or a fixed lump sum
BenefitAmount, term, whether it is level, decreasing or index-linked
TriggerDeath, incapacity under the policy definition, or diagnosis meeting a condition definition
DefinitionsOccupation wording for income protection, critical illness conditions, severity levels and partial payments
UnderwritingNew exclusions, premium loadings, postponements, or anything that differs from your current terms
Waiting and durationDeferred period, benefit period, age when cover ends
PremiumsGuaranteed or reviewable, and the total cost over the full term you need
TrustWhether the existing policy is in trust, and whether the new one will be set up in trust from day one
Linked benefitsWaiver of premium, children's cover, joint-life arrangements, what ends after a claim

Don't compare headline premiums without checking what is insured and for how long. A lower price can reflect a shorter term, a smaller or decreasing sum assured, reviewable rather than guaranteed premiums, or narrower definitions.

A worked example

Tom took out £250,000 of level-term life and critical illness cover, with guaranteed premiums, at 32. Now 40, he's offered a new policy at a slightly lower monthly premium. Before accepting, he checks:

  • Term: the new policy runs to age 60. His current policy runs to 65, when his mortgage ends.
  • Premiums: the new premium is reviewable. His current one is guaranteed.
  • Underwriting: since starting his original policy he has been treated for a back problem. The new insurer's final terms include an exclusion that his existing policy does not have.
  • Critical illness wording: the new policy covers more conditions and includes partial payments.

On balance, the saving comes from a shorter term and a reviewable premium. Tom also gains a new exclusion. The broader critical illness wording is a real advantage, but he decides it does not outweigh the drawbacks. He keeps his existing policy and looks at a small separate critical illness top-up instead. This is an illustration of the trade-offs, not advice for any individual.

The safe order of operations

  1. Review first. Get your existing policy schedule and wording. If you can't find them, ask your insurer for copies.
  2. Apply for the new cover and answer every question fully and accurately. Under the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, mistakes on a new application can affect a future claim.
  3. Wait for the final underwriting decision. An indicative online quote is not an offer.
  4. Compare the final terms with your existing policy, using the table above.
  5. Set up the trust on the new policy, if appropriate, when it starts.
  6. Confirm the new policy is in force: start date confirmed and first premium collected.
  7. Only then decide whether to cancel the old policy, and cancel it with the insurer directly. Stopping the direct debit alone may not formally end the policy.

New life and protection policies normally come with a 30-day cancellation period, which gives you time to change your mind about the new policy. But if you cancel the old one and later want it back, you would usually have to apply again at your new age and health.

Watch out for trusts, joint policies and mortgages

  • Trusts. If your existing policy is written in trust, the trust does not automatically move to a new policy. A new trust needs to be set up, and you should check who the trustees and beneficiaries should be. See our guide to life insurance in trust.
  • Joint policies. Replacing a joint policy with two single policies, or the reverse, changes how and to whom benefits are paid. On separation, both policyholders usually need to agree changes.
  • Mortgage lenders. UK lenders rarely require life cover as a condition of the mortgage today, but check your offer documents if a policy was assigned to the lender.

Questions to ask any adviser who suggests a switch

  • What specific need does the new policy meet that my current one does not?
  • What would I lose, and what would I gain?
  • Has the new insurer accepted my application on final terms?
  • Are the new premiums guaranteed for the full term, or reviewable?
  • Are there any exclusions or restrictions in the new policy that my current one doesn't have?
  • Could I adjust or top up my current policy instead, and how would that compare?
  • How are you paid, and does that differ depending on whether I keep, change or replace my policy?

A good adviser will welcome these questions, put the answers in writing, and be comfortable telling you to keep what you have when that is the better option.

Common questions

Is it worth switching life insurance to save money?

Sometimes. If your health or lifestyle has improved, or the market has moved on, you may find similar cover for less. But compare like for like: same sum assured, same term, guaranteed premiums, and no new exclusions. A saving that comes from less cover is not really a saving.

Will I lose anything by switching?

Possibly. Your existing terms were set at your younger age and earlier health. A new policy may cost more for the same cover, carry new exclusions, or use different definitions. That is why a side-by-side comparison of final terms matters.

Can I switch critical illness cover without losing protection?

Yes, if you keep the existing policy until the new one is in force. Our critical illness switching guide covers the specific points to compare, including condition definitions and partial payments.

The takeaway

Switching can be the right decision, but it should be made on evidence, not on a headline premium. Compare final terms side by side, check trusts and linked benefits, and keep your existing cover until the new policy is confirmed in force. If you'd like an independent second look before deciding, request a free policy review. Keeping what you have is always one of the possible answers.

Sources

What it means for you: A cheaper premium isn't proof of a better policy. Compare final terms side by side, check trusts and new exclusions, and keep your existing cover until the replacement is confirmed in force.
Note: This article is general information and industry commentary, not personal financial advice. Product features, eligibility and any tax treatment depend on your circumstances and the insurer’s terms. Life Insurance For Me is a trading style of More Than Money Ltd, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 1047044). See our regulatory information.

Related on LifeInsuranceForMe

Want cover that fits your job?

Get a free, no-obligation quote from a specialist UK broker.

✓ Free & no obligation✓ 3 quick steps, about 2 minutes✓ FCA regulated