The FCA's 2026 protection market study: what it means for UK households
The regulator has finished its two-year look at how life insurance, critical illness cover and income protection are sold in the UK. The headline isn't that the market is broken. It's that most people never get as far as asking the question.
In short: the Financial Conduct Authority published the final report of its pure protection market study on 21 September 2026. It found that competition generally works well for people who already hold cover, with a wide range of products, high claims acceptance rates and, in general, more than half of premiums paid back out in claims. The concern is the people outside the market: 58% of people hold no protection products at all, and 59% of that group have never considered their protection needs. The FCA is not bringing in new rules. It is coordinating action with insurers, advisers and other organisations, and it expects meaningful progress within 12 to 18 months.
This article explains what the report says, what is likely to change for consumers over the next year or so, and how to use its findings to check your own household's position. It is general information rather than a personal recommendation, and the right answer for some readers will be that they do not need any more cover.
What the FCA looked at
The market study, reference MS24/1, examined how “pure protection” is distributed in the UK. That means products that pay out only on a specified event, with no savings or investment element: term life insurance, critical illness cover, income protection and whole-of-life cover, including guaranteed-acceptance over-50s plans. The FCA looked at the whole chain, from insurers to advisers, brokers, comparison sites and the lead generators that feed them.
It wanted to know two things: whether competition delivers fair value for people who buy, and why so many people do not buy at all. The FCA’s market study page links to the final report, the earlier interim report and the supporting analysis.
The headline findings
- The market works reasonably well for existing customers. The FCA found a wide range of products, high claims acceptance rates, generally more than 50% of premiums paid out in claims, and relatively stable new-business premiums.
- The protection gap is the main problem. 58% of people hold no protection products, and 59% of those have never thought about whether they need any.
- Some groups are particularly exposed. The report names people with pre-existing or complex medical conditions, renters, lower-income households, and people who are self-employed or work in the gig economy.
- A few smaller issues for existing customers. These include some instances of intermediaries switching customers unnecessarily, and requests from the industry for clarity on how premiums can be adjusted for commission. The FCA describes these as limited in scale and not systemic.
Why so many people go without cover
The FCA describes the causes on both sides of the market. On the consumer side, awareness and understanding are low. Many people do not recognise when protection is relevant to them, or never think through what would happen to the household finances after a death, a serious illness or a long spell off work. In the UK, the conversation often happens only once, when a mortgage adviser raises it during a house purchase. That leaves renters, who are about a third of UK households, with no natural moment at which anyone raises the subject.
On the industry side, the report points to long and complicated sales journeys that people abandon, underwriting that can be lengthy or complex, delays in getting medical evidence such as GP reports, unclear product communications, and limited availability for people with more complex needs. Some firms also told the FCA they were not sure whether the rules allowed them to innovate in product design and customer journeys.
What happens next
The FCA's plan has three strands, built on existing rules such as the Consumer Duty rather than new regulation:
- Getting more people to think about protection. Prompts at key life events and financial touchpoints, such as buying a property or planning savings; nudges towards trusts and beneficiary nominations; a sustained market-wide awareness campaign aimed at groups less likely to consider cover; and support to make advisers more confident and consistent when they raise protection.
- A smoother sales process. Bringing stakeholders together to reduce delays in obtaining medical records, and supporting initiatives to improve access for people with variable or precarious incomes.
- Supporting innovation. A possible FCA TechSprint in the third quarter of 2027 on technology-led solutions, and a “myth-busting” webinar for firms about regulatory expectations.
The timetable on the FCA's site has engagement with industry starting in October 2026, industry-led work beginning by the end of 2026, and meaningful progress expected within 12 to 18 months. None of this changes your existing policy or creates a new right to cover. It is a direction of travel. Over time, though, you may notice more prompts about protection from lenders, banks, pension providers and employers.
Two findings that matter if you already have cover
Over-50s guaranteed-acceptance plans
The FCA looked closely at guaranteed-acceptance over-50s plans, which pay a fixed lump sum with no medical questions. It concluded that they have an important place in the market, especially for people who cannot get, or prefer not to apply for, underwritten cover. It also found that for people in good health, they can be more expensive than a comparable underwritten whole-of-life policy, particularly at lower sums assured. In its survey, 28% of respondents said they chose a guaranteed-acceptance plan because of the guaranteed acceptance itself. If you are in reasonable health and considering one of these plans, it is worth comparing it with underwritten options first. Our over-50s guide explains the difference.
Unnecessary switching
The FCA found a risk that commission structures could encourage some intermediaries to move customers to a new policy once the original commission can no longer be clawed back, even when the new policy does not suit them better. It estimated that around 19,000 customers a year may be affected, roughly 0.1% of policyholders, and decided that market-wide intervention would be disproportionate. Its supervisors will instead target firms that behave badly. If someone suggests replacing your cover, see our switching checklist before you agree to anything.
Using the findings: a five-minute household check
The most useful thing a reader can take from the report is the question it says most people never ask: what would stop working if something happened to me? Start with events, not products.
- If the main earner died: could the household keep paying the mortgage or rent, council tax, energy bills, childcare and food? For how many years?
- If someone could not work for six months: what income would carry on? Check employer sick pay, Statutory Sick Pay (if eligible), a partner's income and savings.
- If someone had a serious illness: would the household cope with reduced hours, adaptations to the home or travel to treatment?
Then list what already exists:
| What you may already have | Where to check | What to watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Death-in-service benefit | Employer benefits booklet or HR | Usually ends if you leave the job. Often a multiple of salary |
| Employer sick pay | Contract of employment or staff handbook | How long full and half pay last before dropping to SSP |
| Existing personal policies | Policy schedule and annual statements | Term end date, whether the sum reduces, whether it is in trust |
| Savings | Bank and ISA balances | Only count money you would genuinely use |
| State support | GOV.UK and MoneyHelper | Usually means-tested and not designed to replace earnings |
The difference between what you would need and what you have is your protection gap, if there is one. Some households will find they are well covered by an employer and savings. Others, especially renters, self-employed people and single-income families, often find a gap they had not noticed. Our earlier guide to the UK protection gap goes through a worked household example.
What “good” should look like when you do get advice
The report gives a useful benchmark for any protection conversation, whether with us or anyone else. You should come away understanding:
- which risk each product addresses. Life cover, critical illness cover and income protection solve different problems, and one is not a substitute for the others;
- what would and would not trigger a payment, including the key definitions and exclusions;
- whether premiums are guaranteed or reviewable, and what the cover costs over its full term;
- what you must disclose on the application, and why accurate answers protect a future claim;
- whether the policy should be written in trust. The FCA specifically wants more people prompted about trusts. See our guide to life insurance in trust;
- how the adviser or broker is paid.
The cheapest premium is not a complete measure of suitability. Two policies at similar prices can have quite different definitions, deferred periods or claim terms. This is where an adviser who compares the whole market can add value, and where an online quote alone can miss things. Our how we compare page sets out what we look at.
Common questions
Does the FCA report mean I need to buy protection?
No. The FCA's point is that people should make an informed decision, and that includes deciding not to buy. If you have no dependants, no debts that someone else would inherit, and enough savings or employer benefits to cover a long absence, you may not need more cover.
Will this make life insurance cheaper?
The report does not promise lower prices. Faster access to medical records and simpler underwriting could make applying easier, especially for people with complex medical histories, but price will still depend on your age, health, occupation and the cover you choose.
I was declined in the past. Does anything change now?
Not immediately. The FCA wants better access for people with pre-existing conditions, but that will come through industry initiatives over time. In the meantime, a decline from one insurer is not necessarily a decline from all of them. See our guide on what to do after being declined.
Should I replace my existing policy because of the report?
No. Nothing in the report suggests existing policyholders should switch. If your circumstances have changed, a policy review can check whether your current cover still fits. Always keep existing cover in force until any replacement has been accepted and is on risk.
The takeaway
The FCA's message is reassuring for people who already hold cover and pointed for the industry: too many households never get the conversation at all. You do not need to wait for a prompt from your bank or lender. Work through the household check above, write down what you already have, and get any gaps explained in plain English before deciding anything.
Sources
- FCA, Pure Protection Market Study (MS24/1): Final Report, 21 September 2026
- FCA, Market study into the distribution of pure protection products: updates and timetable
Go Deeper