📰 Insights · Regulation

Consumer Duty and protection: what 'fair value' means for you

The FCA's Consumer Duty has quietly reset the standard the whole industry is measured against. Here is the customer's-eye view.

At its heart, Consumer Duty asks firms to deliver good outcomes rather than simply sell products. For protection that means cover should represent fair value, be clearly explained, and genuinely suit the person buying it — with support that does not fall away the moment the policy is in force.

In practice you should expect plain-English explanations of what is and is not covered, no pressure to buy add-ons that do not fit, and an adviser who can show why a recommendation suits your circumstances. It has also pushed firms to look harder at whether customers understand key features — like deferred periods and definitions of incapacity — before they sign.

For a broker, the Duty reinforces what good advice always looked like: match the cover to the person, be upfront about exclusions, and stay contactable when it matters most — at claim time.

What the Consumer Duty is

The Consumer Duty is a set of FCA rules that came into force on 31 July 2023 for products currently on sale, and on 31 July 2024 for closed products that are no longer sold but still held by customers. It requires regulated firms to act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers, to act in good faith, to avoid causing foreseeable harm, and to support customers in pursuing their financial objectives.

Rather than setting a list of detailed rules for every situation, the Duty sets a higher overall standard and asks firms to evidence that they meet it. That applies to insurers who design protection products and to advisers and brokers who recommend them.

The four outcomes, from a customer's point of view

The FCA groups the Duty into four outcomes. Each one translates into something practical you can expect when buying protection.

  • Products and services — products should be designed to meet the needs of a clearly identified group of customers, and sold to the people they are designed for. A policy built for office workers should not be sold to a scaffolder without explaining the differences.
  • Price and value — the price you pay should be reasonable relative to the benefits you receive. That includes the cost of advice and any commission.
  • Consumer understanding — information should be clear and timely enough for you to make an informed decision, including about exclusions, waiting periods and definitions.
  • Consumer support — it should be as easy to make a claim, change your policy or complain as it was to buy the cover in the first place.

What this means when you take out cover

You should be told how your adviser is paid and whether they search the whole market or a panel of insurers. You should receive a recommendation that explains why the policy suits your circumstances, not just a quote. Key features — what the policy pays, when it pays and what it excludes — should be explained in plain English, and you should have the chance to ask questions before you commit.

If something does not make sense, ask for it to be explained again. Under the Duty, the responsibility to make information understandable sits with the firm, not with you.

What this means at claim time

The consumer support outcome matters most when you need to claim. Firms should not create unreasonable barriers, such as complicated processes, long delays or difficulty reaching a person. Insurers have also been encouraged to look at how they treat customers in vulnerable circumstances — including people with serious illness or bereavement — and to adapt their approach accordingly.

What to do if you are not happy

If you feel you have not been treated fairly, you can complain to the firm involved. If they do not resolve the complaint to your satisfaction within eight weeks, or you disagree with their final response, you can usually refer it to the Financial Ombudsman Service free of charge. Our regulatory information page sets out how complaints are handled and who regulates us.

How fair value is judged

Fair value does not mean the cheapest price. It means the overall price you pay is reasonable relative to the benefits you receive. Insurers must assess their products regularly, looking at factors such as how often claims are paid, how many customers cancel early, and whether particular groups of customers receive poorer outcomes than others.

For protection, that assessment includes the whole package: the premium, the scope of cover, the exclusions, the claims service and any added-value support such as remote GP access or rehabilitation services. A policy with a slightly higher premium but broader cover and a strong claims record may represent better value than a cheaper one that excludes the risks you are most likely to face. A good adviser should explain these differences rather than steering you towards the lowest headline price.

A practical checklist

  • Do you understand what the policy pays out for and what it excludes?
  • Do you know how your adviser is paid?
  • Has the adviser explained why this policy suits you?
  • Do you know how to make a claim and who to contact?

If the answer to any of these is no, you are entitled to ask before you sign.

What it means for you: Under Consumer Duty you are entitled to clear information and cover that genuinely fits — never settle for less.
Note: This article is general information and industry commentary, not personal financial advice. Product features, eligibility and any tax treatment depend on your circumstances and the insurer’s terms. Life Insurance For Me is a trading style of More Than Money Ltd, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 1047044). See our regulatory information.

Related on LifeInsuranceForMe

Want cover that fits your job?

Get a free, no-obligation quote from a specialist UK broker.

✓ Free & no obligation✓ 3 quick steps, about 2 minutes✓ FCA regulated